Posted inSurvival Games

Which Survival Game Reigns Supreme: A Comprehensive Analysis

The world of survival games is a wildly popular genre, with a multitude of titles vying for the top spot. From the harsh terrain of the wilderness to the post-apocalyptic world, these games put players in the heart of the action, requiring them to survive against all odds. But which game reigns supreme? In this comprehensive analysis, we’ll dive deep into the world of survival games, examining the most popular titles and what makes them stand out from the rest. So, buckle up and get ready to discover which survival game rules the roost.

Survival Games: A Thriving Genre

The Evolution of Survival Games

Early Pioneers

Survival games have their roots in the late 1970s with the release of Beyond Castle Wolfenstein, a text-based adventure game where players had to navigate through a maze of corridors, collect weapons, and defeat enemies. The game introduced a new dimension to gaming by emphasizing survival elements such as food and health management.

The 1990s: A New Era

The 1990s saw a significant evolution in the survival game genre with the release of games like Dune II: The Building of a Desert Planet and The Settlers. These games introduced strategic elements and expanded upon the survival mechanics introduced in Beyond Castle Wolfenstein.

The 2000s: The Rise of Open-World Survival Games

The 2000s marked a turning point for survival games with the release of The Legend of Zelda: Shadow of the Colossus and Fallout 3. These games expanded upon the concept of open-world gaming, providing players with vast environments to explore and survive in.

The 2010s: The Golden Age of Survival Games

The 2010s saw the emergence of several critically acclaimed survival games, including Don’t Starve, The Forest, and Subnautica. These games introduced unique mechanics and immersive worlds, pushing the boundaries of what was possible in the survival genre.

The Present Day: A Continuously Evolving Genre

Today, survival games continue to evolve and diversify, with new titles being released regularly. From the sandbox-style gameplay of Astroneer to the psychological horror of The Long Dark, the genre remains as popular as ever. As technology advances and developers push the limits of what is possible, survival games are poised to continue their ascent as one of the most exciting and engaging genres in gaming.

The Appeal of Survival Games

Atmospheric Immersion

One of the primary reasons for the appeal of survival games is their ability to immerse players in a rich, atmospheric world. These games often feature intricate environments with harsh weather conditions, dangerous wildlife, and treacherous terrain, forcing players to navigate through hostile environments and adapt to their surroundings. The immersive qualities of survival games allow players to feel as though they are truly part of the game world, making it easy to become fully engrossed in the experience.

Challenging Gameplay

Another factor contributing to the popularity of survival games is their challenging nature. These games often require players to manage resources, craft tools, and hunt for food, all while trying to evade dangerous predators and other threats. The demanding gameplay mechanics create a sense of accomplishment when players successfully overcome obstacles and challenges, adding to the overall satisfaction of the gaming experience.

Skill Progression and Adaptability

Survival games typically involve a strong emphasis on skill progression and adaptability, encouraging players to continuously improve their abilities and strategies. As players progress through the game, they often unlock new tools, weapons, and abilities, allowing them to overcome increasingly difficult challenges. This aspect of survival games provides a sense of progression and accomplishment, keeping players engaged and motivated to continue playing.

Emotional Connection and Storytelling

In addition to immersive environments and challenging gameplay, many survival games also incorporate compelling storytelling and character development. These narrative elements often create an emotional connection between players and the game world, driving players to become invested in the fates of their characters and the stories unfolding around them. This emotional connection further enhances the overall experience of survival games, encouraging players to invest their time and effort into the game world.

The Top Contenders

Key takeaway: Survival games have become increasingly popular in recent years, with many different titles vying for the top spot. These games offer immersive atmospheres, challenging gameplay, and a sense of progression and community engagement. The top contenders in the genre include Minecraft, Rust, and The Forest, each offering a unique blend of gameplay mechanics and content. However, it is important to note that player preferences and opinions may vary.

Game #1: Minecraft

Minecraft is a sandbox survival game developed by Mojang Studios and released in 2011. It has since become one of the best-selling video games of all time, with over 200 million copies sold across multiple platforms. The game’s popularity is largely due to its unique gameplay, which combines elements of survival, exploration, and creativity.

In Minecraft, players are placed in a blocky 3D world where they must gather resources, build shelter, and fend off monsters to survive. The game is divided into two main modes: Survival and Creative. In Survival mode, players must gather resources and build shelter to survive, while in Creative mode, players have unlimited resources and can focus on building without the threat of monsters.

Graphics and Sound
Minecraft’s blocky graphics may not be the most sophisticated, but they are charming and unique. The game’s sound design is equally impressive, with a range of atmospheric sound effects and a hauntingly beautiful soundtrack.

Community and Modding
Minecraft has a massive and dedicated community of players who have created countless mods and custom maps. The game’s modding community has been responsible for some of the most innovative and creative content in gaming history.

Comparisons and Conclusion
While Minecraft may not be the most traditional survival game, its unique blend of gameplay elements and massive community make it a contender for the title of best survival game. Whether you prefer the challenge of Survival mode or the creativity of Creative mode, Minecraft has something for everyone.

Game #2: Rust

Rust is a survival game developed by Facepunch Studios that has gained a massive following since its release in 2013. It is set in a post-apocalyptic world where players must scavenge for resources, build shelter, and fend off other players in order to survive.

One of the key features of Rust is its emphasis on player interaction. The game has no specific objectives or quests, and players are free to explore the world and interact with others as they see fit. This has led to a strong community of players who engage in a variety of activities, from building elaborate bases to engaging in PvP combat.

Rust’s world is procedurally generated, meaning that each time a player starts a new game, the landscape is different. This adds a layer of unpredictability to the game and keeps players on their toes. The world is also filled with dangerous wildlife, from bears and wolves to poisonous snakes and scorpions, adding another layer of challenge to the game.

The game’s crafting system is also a standout feature. Players must gather resources and craft weapons, tools, and other items in order to survive. The crafting system is deep and complex, with multiple tiers of items and a large number of recipes to discover. This adds a level of strategy to the game, as players must carefully manage their resources and prioritize their crafting efforts.

Another key aspect of Rust is its focus on player progression. The game features a skill tree that allows players to unlock new abilities and perks as they play. This adds a sense of progression and encourages players to continue playing and improving their skills.

Overall, Rust is a challenging and immersive survival game that offers a unique experience for players. Its focus on player interaction and progression, combined with its deep crafting system and procedurally generated world, make it a standout title in the genre.

Game #3: The Forest

The Forest is a first-person survival horror game developed by Endnight Games. Players find themselves stranded on a remote island, with a dense forest as their only refuge from the supernatural threats lurking in the surrounding areas. The game’s immersive atmosphere and challenging gameplay have made it a fan favorite in the survival genre.

Atmosphere and Setting

The Forest excels in creating a foreboding atmosphere, thanks to its detailed environments and eerie sound design. The dense forest is a living, breathing world, with dynamic weather systems and intricate foliage that creates a sense of isolation and unease. The game’s supernatural elements, such as the hostile creatures and otherworldly phenomena, add to the tension and keep players on edge.

Survival Mechanics

Survival in The Forest is a challenging endeavor, as players must scavenge for resources, build shelter, and fend off hostile creatures to stay alive. The game features a day-night cycle, with different challenges and opportunities presented during each phase. During the day, players can explore the island, gather resources, and fortify their shelter. At night, they must huddle in their shelter and fend off hostile creatures using makeshift weapons and traps.

Crafting and Progression

The Forest’s crafting system is an integral part of the gameplay, as players must gather resources to create tools, weapons, and shelter. The game features a deep crafting system, with multiple tiers of items and upgrades. As players progress, they can unlock new recipes and crafting techniques, allowing them to create more advanced gear and fortify their shelter.

Combat and Enemies

Combat in The Forest is a tense and challenging experience, as players must use stealth, traps, and makeshift weapons to fend off hostile creatures. The game features a variety of supernatural enemies, each with unique behaviors and strengths. Players must learn the patterns and weaknesses of each enemy to survive the night and progress through the game.

Story and World Building

The Forest’s story is primarily told through environmental storytelling and cryptic notes scattered throughout the game world. Players must piece together the island’s dark history and uncover the mysteries behind the supernatural threats. The game’s world-building is intricate and immersive, with a rich lore and backstory that adds depth to the gameplay.

In conclusion, The Forest is a standout survival game that combines immersive atmosphere, challenging gameplay, and intricate world-building to create a unique and memorable experience. Its supernatural elements and dynamic gameplay make it a must-play for fans of the genre.

Factors Contributing to Popularity

Immersive Storylines

  • Immersive storylines have become a key component in the success of survival games, allowing players to become fully engrossed in the game world and its characters.
  • Many survival games have complex narratives that explore themes such as survival, human nature, and morality, which can make for a compelling and thought-provoking experience for players.
  • For example, games like “The Last of Us” and “The Walking Dead” have received critical acclaim for their well-crafted stories and characters, which have helped to establish them as some of the most popular survival games in recent years.
  • In addition to offering a captivating story, immersive storylines also contribute to the replayability of survival games, as players may want to experience different outcomes or explore different paths within the game’s narrative.
  • The ability to make choices that impact the outcome of the story can also add a sense of agency and investment for players, making the experience even more immersive and engaging.
  • Overall, immersive storylines are a crucial aspect of many successful survival games, and their continued development and innovation is likely to play a major role in the ongoing popularity of the genre.

Challenging Gameplay

  • The appeal of survival games lies in their ability to present players with a formidable challenge, pushing them to the limits of their skills and mental fortitude.
  • A key aspect of challenging gameplay is the balance between providing players with a sense of accomplishment when they overcome obstacles and ensuring that failure feels like a natural consequence of their actions, rather than a result of unfair mechanics.
  • To achieve this balance, developers must carefully design the game’s systems, including player character abilities, enemy behavior, and resource management, to create a cohesive experience that encourages strategic thinking and adaptability.
  • In addition to well-designed systems, the environment itself plays a crucial role in creating a challenging experience. Harsh weather conditions, treacherous terrain, and dangerous wildlife can all contribute to a sense of peril and uncertainty that keeps players on edge.
  • To maintain player engagement, survival games must also provide a sense of progression and reward. This can be achieved through unlocking new abilities or equipment, discovering new areas, or overcoming increasingly difficult challenges.
  • Finally, replayability is a critical aspect of challenging gameplay in survival games. By incorporating random elements, such as procedurally generated environments or dynamic weather patterns, developers can ensure that each playthrough feels unique and challenging, encouraging players to continue attempting to overcome the game’s obstacles.

The Role of Community and Content Creators

The Importance of Community Engagement

The survival game genre has experienced immense popularity, and a significant factor contributing to this success is the strong sense of community engagement. The players of these games are not only interested in playing the game but also actively participate in discussing and sharing their experiences with others. This has led to the formation of dedicated communities around specific survival games, where players can share tips, strategies, and stories with one another.

Content Creators as Influencers

Content creators, such as streamers and YouTubers, have played a pivotal role in promoting survival games and driving their popularity. These creators often showcase their gameplay experiences, provide tips and tutorials, and share their thoughts on various aspects of the game. This content serves as a valuable resource for other players, as it helps them understand the game mechanics, strategies, and potential challenges they may face.

Collaboration and Cross-Promotion

Collaboration between survival game developers and content creators has proven to be a powerful marketing strategy. Many developers collaborate with popular content creators to showcase their games and generate buzz around the release of new updates or DLCs. This partnership not only benefits the developers by reaching a wider audience but also helps content creators to expand their reach and gain more exposure.

The Impact of User-Generated Content

User-generated content, such as custom maps, mods, and community-driven projects, has significantly contributed to the popularity of survival games. These creations allow players to experiment with new gameplay mechanics, explore unique environments, and engage in innovative challenges that may not be available in the base game. This continuous stream of new content keeps the games fresh and encourages players to return and explore more.

In conclusion, the role of community and content creators in the survival game genre cannot be overstated. They foster a sense of engagement, provide valuable resources and insights, and contribute to the overall success and longevity of these games.

Comparing the Top Contenders

Background and Overview

Minecraft, developed by Mojang Studios, is a sandbox survival game that has taken the world by storm since its release in 2011. With its blocky 3D graphics and infinite procedurally generated world, it has become a phenomenon, selling over 200 million copies across multiple platforms.

Core Mechanics

The core mechanics of Minecraft revolve around gathering resources, crafting tools and weapons, and building structures to survive against hostile mobs, such as zombies, skeletons, and creepers. Players must also manage their hunger and thirst, making sure to eat food and drink water to stay alive.

Survival Mode

In Survival Mode, players start with no weapons or armor and must gather resources to craft basic tools and weapons to defend themselves against the nightly monster attacks. The objective is to survive as long as possible while building structures and exploring the world.

Creative Mode

In Creative Mode, players have unlimited resources and can focus on building without the pressure of survival. This mode allows players to let their creativity run wild, creating elaborate structures and designs without the constraints of hunger, thirst, or danger.


Minecraft supports multiplayer mode, allowing players to join together in the same world to build and explore. Players can choose to work together or compete against each other in various game modes, such as “Survival” or “Battle.”

Comparing to Other Survival Games

Compared to other survival games, Minecraft’s unique blend of blocky graphics and open-ended gameplay sets it apart. While it lacks the realism and intensity of other survival games, it makes up for it with its creative freedom and endless possibilities.


Overall, Minecraft’s addictive gameplay, creative freedom, and massive player base make it a force to be reckoned with in the survival game genre. Its unique style and approach to survival make it a must-play for anyone interested in the genre.

Gameplay Mechanics

Rust is a multiplayer survival game developed by Facepunch Studios. It is known for its unique combination of elements from various genres, including survival, crafting, and shooting. The game’s core gameplay mechanics revolve around scavenging for resources, building shelter, and fighting off other players in a post-apocalyptic world.

Scavenging and Crafting

Rust’s survival aspect requires players to scavenge for resources to gather materials and craft weapons and tools. Players must explore the game’s world to find these resources, which can be used to build structures, weapons, and other essential items. Crafting is an integral part of the game, as it allows players to create a wide variety of items, from simple tools to advanced machinery.

Building and Base Defense

Rust also features a strong emphasis on base building and defense. Players must construct shelter and defenses to protect their resources and equipment from other players. The game features a wide variety of building materials and components, allowing players to create complex structures and fortifications. Base defense is crucial in Rust, as other players can and will attack and raid bases to obtain resources and equipment.

PvP and Player Interaction

Rust’s PvP (player versus player) aspect is a significant part of the game. Players can choose to cooperate with each other, forming alliances and sharing resources, or they can engage in combat and aggression to obtain what they need. The game’s player interaction system is complex, with a deep metagame involving clans, alliances, and rivalries.

Progression and Content

Rust features a non-linear progression system, with players starting with basic tools and weapons and working their way up to more advanced equipment. The game features a wide variety of content, including resource locations, landmarks, and points of interest. Players must explore the game’s world to discover new resources and opportunities for progression.

Graphics and Sound Design

Rust’s graphics are simple yet effective, with a focus on environmental detail and immersion. The game’s sound design is equally impressive, with a haunting and atmospheric score that enhances the game’s post-apocalyptic setting.

Replayability and Community

Rust is known for its strong community and replayability. The game’s sandbox-style gameplay and emergent gameplay opportunities allow for a wide variety of experiences and strategies. The game’s community is active and engaged, with a dedicated player base that shares mods, servers, and custom content.

Overall, Rust is a unique and challenging survival game that combines elements from various genres to create a truly immersive and engaging experience. Its focus on base building, player interaction, and PvP gameplay make it a standout in the survival genre.


The Forest is a survival horror game developed by Endnight Games, a small independent studio. Released in 2018, the game has garnered critical acclaim for its immersive gameplay and unique setting. Players find themselves stranded on a mysterious island, where they must survive against all odds while unraveling the secrets of the island.

The Forest offers a vast open-world environment for players to explore, with a day-night cycle that adds an extra layer of realism to the game. The game’s primary objective is to survive, which involves gathering resources, building shelter, and fending off hostile creatures. Players must also keep track of their hunger, thirst, and health, which adds an extra layer of challenge to the game.

Crafting System

The Forest features a robust crafting system that allows players to create a wide variety of tools and weapons. Players can gather resources such as wood, rocks, and metal to craft weapons, tools, and shelter. The crafting system adds a strategic element to the game, as players must decide which resources to prioritize and how to best use them.

Story and Setting

The Forest’s story is primarily driven by the player’s exploration and discovery of the island. The island is filled with mysterious ruins and artifacts, which hint at a deeper history and mythology. The game’s setting is dark and foreboding, with dense forests, eerie caves, and dangerous creatures lurking around every corner.


The Forest features a unique multiplayer mode, where players can team up and build shelters together. This adds a social element to the game, as players must work together to survive and build their civilization. The multiplayer mode also introduces new challenges, such as managing resources and coordinating efforts with other players.

The Forest’s graphics are top-notch, with stunning visuals that bring the island to life. The game’s sound design is equally impressive, with realistic sound effects and a haunting score that adds to the game’s atmosphere.


The Forest offers a high degree of replayability, with a vast open-world environment and a randomized map. Each playthrough offers a unique experience, as players must adapt to different weather conditions, resource locations, and creatures. The game’s crafting system and multiplayer mode also add to the replayability factor, as players can experiment with different strategies and playstyles.

Final Thoughts

The Forest is a standout survival game that offers a unique blend of exploration, crafting, and multiplayer gameplay. Its immersive setting and challenging gameplay mechanics make it a must-play for fans of the genre. With its vast open-world environment, deep crafting system, and haunting sound design, The Forest is a top contender for the title of best survival game.

The Undeniable Leader

The undeniable leader among survival games is without a doubt PlayerUnknown’s Battlegrounds (PUBG). This game has taken the world by storm since its release in 2017, with its unique battle royale gameplay that pits up to 100 players against each other in a fight for survival.

One of the key reasons behind PUBG’s success is its attention to detail and realism. The game’s developers have created a vast, sprawling map with multiple environments, from urban cities to rural landscapes, each with its own unique challenges and opportunities for survival. The game’s weaponry is also highly realistic, with a wide variety of firearms and attachments that players can use to gain an advantage over their opponents.

Another reason for PUBG’s dominance is its frequent updates and improvements. The game’s developers are constantly adding new content, such as seasons, events, and game modes, to keep the game fresh and exciting for players. Additionally, the game’s performance is consistently excellent, with smooth graphics and minimal lag even on older computers.

PUBG’s success has also spawned a large esports scene, with numerous professional teams and players competing in tournaments and leagues around the world. This has helped to further solidify PUBG’s position as the leader in the survival game genre.

In conclusion, PlayerUnknown’s Battlegrounds is the undeniable leader among survival games. Its attention to detail, realism, frequent updates, and large esports scene have all contributed to its success and made it a staple in the gaming world.

The Future of Survival Games

Advancements in Technology

One of the most significant factors that will shape the future of survival games is the advancements in technology. As technology continues to evolve, game developers will have access to more advanced tools and resources, which will allow them to create more immersive and realistic survival games. This includes improved graphics, more advanced AI, and better physics simulations. These advancements will enable players to experience a more engaging and authentic survival experience, which will ultimately enhance the overall gaming experience.

Diversification of Genres

Another trend that is likely to shape the future of survival games is the diversification of genres. Survival games have traditionally been associated with the adventure and survival genres, but in the future, we can expect to see more crossovers with other genres such as horror, action, and even strategy. This will introduce new gameplay mechanics and challenges, which will keep players engaged and interested in the genre.

Emphasis on Multiplayer Experiences

Finally, the future of survival games is likely to place a greater emphasis on multiplayer experiences. With the rise of online gaming and the popularity of multiplayer games, it is only natural that survival games will begin to incorporate more multiplayer elements. This could include cooperative gameplay, competitive game modes, and even social features such as leaderboards and in-game chat. These multiplayer experiences will help to foster a sense of community among players, which will be crucial in maintaining the popularity of the genre.

In conclusion, the future of survival games looks bright, with a range of exciting developments on the horizon. From advancements in technology to diversification of genres and an emphasis on multiplayer experiences, there is much to look forward to for fans of the genre.

The Impact on the Gaming Industry

The rise of survival games in the gaming industry has had a profound impact on the way games are designed, marketed, and played. These games have not only captured the imagination of players worldwide but have also revolutionized the way developers approach game design.

One of the key factors contributing to the success of survival games is their ability to evoke a sense of challenge and excitement in players. These games require players to adapt to harsh environments, scavenge for resources, and build shelter to survive. The level of difficulty and complexity can vary widely, making them accessible to a broad audience.

Survival games have also introduced new gameplay mechanics that have become popular in other genres. For example, the crafting system, where players gather resources to create tools and items, has become a staple in many games. The emphasis on survival skills and resource management has also inspired developers to create games that focus on exploration, strategy, and problem-solving.

Moreover, survival games have provided a new platform for indie developers to showcase their creativity and innovation. Many successful survival games have been developed by small teams or individuals, demonstrating that success in the gaming industry is not limited to large studios with massive budgets. This has encouraged a new wave of innovation and experimentation in game design, leading to the emergence of new subgenres and styles.

The impact of survival games on the gaming industry has also been felt in the realm of esports. Many survival games, such as PUBG and Fortnite, have become popular in the competitive gaming scene, attracting millions of viewers and players worldwide. This has led to the development of new tournaments, leagues, and streaming platforms, further driving the growth of the gaming industry.

Overall, the success of survival games has had a profound impact on the gaming industry, inspiring new game design trends, encouraging innovation, and fueling the growth of esports. As the genre continues to evolve, it will be exciting to see how survival games shape the future of gaming.

The Enduring Appeal of Survival Games

The survival game genre has captured the hearts of gamers worldwide with its gripping narratives and intense gameplay. The appeal of these games lies in their ability to challenge players to survive against all odds, pushing them to their limits and beyond.

One of the key factors contributing to the enduring appeal of survival games is their immersive atmospheres. These games transport players to remote, unfamiliar environments, such as harsh wildernesses, post-apocalyptic landscapes, or mysterious islands, where they must struggle to stay alive. The intricate world-building, attention to detail, and realistic environments all contribute to a sense of believability that draws players in and keeps them engaged.

Challenge and Mastery

Survival games are notorious for their difficulty, as they present players with a myriad of challenges that require skill, strategy, and perseverance. These challenges may include managing hunger, thirst, and temperature, scavenging for resources, crafting tools and weapons, fending off hostile creatures, and navigating treacherous terrain. As players progress, they develop a sense of accomplishment and mastery over their environment, which fuels their desire to continue pushing forward.

Emotional Investment

Another reason why survival games have such a strong appeal is their ability to evoke powerful emotions in players. Whether it’s the fear of being hunted by predators, the desperation of searching for food and water, or the satisfaction of overcoming seemingly insurmountable obstacles, these games elicit a wide range of emotions that keep players invested in the story and gameplay. The emotional journey of the protagonist, whether they are stranded on a deserted island, battling for survival in a post-apocalyptic world, or navigating a haunted wilderness, adds a layer of depth and nuance to the gameplay experience.

Narrative Depth

Many survival games incorporate compelling narratives that drive the gameplay forward and provide context for the player’s actions. These narratives may involve a search for rescue, a quest for revenge, a mission to uncover the truth, or a personal journey of self-discovery. The narrative depth in these games often exceeds expectations, delving into themes of human nature, morality, and the human condition, while also providing players with meaningful choices and consequences that shape the course of the story.

In conclusion, the enduring appeal of survival games lies in their ability to transport players to immersive worlds, challenge them to overcome seemingly insurmountable obstacles, evoke powerful emotions, and present narratives that resonate on a deeper level. As the popularity of these games continues to soar, developers are tasked with pushing the boundaries of the genre, innovating new mechanics, and delivering unforgettable experiences that will keep players hooked for years to come.


1. What is a survival game?

A survival game is a type of video game that focuses on the player’s ability to survive in a harsh environment or situation. These games often require players to gather resources, build shelter, and make difficult decisions in order to stay alive.

2. What are some popular survival games?

There are many popular survival games, including “The Forest,” “Rust,” “Don’t Starve,” “Subnautica,” and “Stranded Deep.” Each of these games offers a unique survival experience, with different challenges and mechanics.

3. Which survival game is the most popular?

It’s difficult to say which survival game is the most popular, as popularity can vary depending on the region and audience. However, “Minecraft” is often considered one of the most popular survival games, with millions of players worldwide. “Rust” has also gained a large following, particularly among the PC gaming community.

4. What makes a survival game successful?

A successful survival game typically offers a compelling and immersive world, challenging gameplay mechanics, and a sense of progression and accomplishment. A good survival game also offers a strong sense of community, whether through multiplayer options or online forums where players can share tips and strategies.

5. How do survival games differ from other genres?

Survival games often differ from other genres in that they place a strong emphasis on player survival and resource management. In many survival games, the player must gather resources, build shelter, and make difficult decisions in order to stay alive. This contrasts with other genres, such as action or role-playing games, which may focus more on combat or exploration.

The Most Detailed Survival Game?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *